MANNING UP part 2
Unpacking the troubles in yer old kit bag

I’ve been thinking a lot recently about toxic masculinity and the concept of ‘Manning Up’, some of you might have read my previous poston this.
Its brought to mind ‘Pack up yer troubles in yer Old Kit Bag’ which was written in 1915 by George Powell and was the winner of a marching song competition for British troops during the first world war.
Originally penned as an uplifting and cheerful ditty it symbolises that central tenet of traditional masculinity that by burying your feelings and carrying on as if everything was just fine you’ll somehow be… just fine.
I was brought up on this, and many similar ideas and have believed them implicitly my whole life but events in the last twelve months, not least of all Life Coach training with Animas, has caused me to re-evaluate much of it.
I attended a memorial service last week for a friend and colleague called Catriona, a guidance teacher at the High School. She and I had worked with some of the same young people and and on a bright but cold weekday afternoon a group of us remembered her by planting a tree in the grounds. We stood round it in a big circle while people shared some of their recollections. She was a lovely person, the mum that so many of the young people present wished they’d had.
A young man called Kenny who’d I’d worked with myself last year, and who’d had his fair share of difficulties in school, spoke about how he’d begun high school filled with excitement and anticipation of all the new friends he’d make.
It hadn’t panned out that way and he shared how he’d followed a path of isolating himself, burying his feelings and, when necessary, using his fists.
Many of us know this as ‘Manning Up’, that ancient and deeply ingrained formula for dealing with adversity.
I’d always enjoyed working with Kenny. He’d had good days and bad but we had discovered early in our acquaintance a mutual ability with accents and mimicry, our favourite being the upper class Englishman, and we’d regularly exchange clipped observations and truisms;
‘Least said soonest mended old boy’
‘Yes, quite, no use crying over spilled milk, what?’
Inronically in pretending to be stiff upper lip, emotionless cliches we were often able to find a degree of trust and understanding.
Kenny was clearly struggling as he spoke. Like so many of the students gathered there Catriona had been a hugely important figure in his life and the tragedy of her loss was all too evident on the faces around me. But it was the poignancy with which he described his bewilderment, disappointment and anger at being rejected and ridiculed that really brought a lump to my throat.
I can remember very vividly the cruelty and violence that was commonplace from my own school days and how this was gleefully visited on anyone who showed the least sensitivity or capacity for emotional coherence. I learned to cultivate a thick skin.
He went on to describe how Catriona had just listened and gently encouraged while he struggled to deal with the anger he was feeling, how she’d never judged but had always been honest with him.
As someone who has had the opportunity of being present while people share deeply painful recollections, I could see that he was right back there in the midst of the worst of them as he spoke but he carried on bravely, not even pausing to wipe away the tears. I was so proud of him.
After a pause he stared meaningfully round at all of us and beseeched the other kids not to make the mistake he had early on of thinking he could tough it out alone.
They came from a client group I’m familiar with and catching and holding their attention can be a challenge but there was a pin drop silence while Kenny spoke, despite the blustering wind and cold.
I’d known Kenny as a thoughtful, intelligent guy with a wicked sense of humour but hearing him speak now I realised he also had great courage, a genuine concern for people who are going through the same things as him and an ability to fight his demons, not by burying them but by dragging them out into the light and facing them down.
Moving forward, and from a coaching perspective, I like the idea of using the title of this familiar song as a start point for unpacking - and thereby horizontalising - the items in our metaphorical kit bags so that they can be examined in the coaching space. Furthermore, there are the implications that the song itself had for an entire generation of men. Men like my Great Grandfatherwho returned from the trenches and were simply expected to pick up their previous lives as if nothing had happened.
From a personal perspective I’m going to have to get a lot better at doing it myself but Kenny, strength to him, has set me a most impressive example.









